The BMW S85 engine, found in the E60 M5 and E63/E64 M6, is a high-revving masterpiece. However, it’s also known for a significant vulnerability: rod bearing failure. This article solves 3 problems: It provides actionable strategies for deciding when and how to tackle the s85 rod bearing replacement, offers unique perspectives on preventative maintenance, and shares first-hand experiences to guide your decision-making process.
The big question isn’t if you’ll need to replace the rod bearings on your S85, but when. Mileage is a factor, but driving style and maintenance history play a far bigger role. Many owners opt for preventative replacement, while others wait for telltale signs.
Analyzing Oil Samples: A Window into Your Engine’s Health
One of the most effective ways to monitor rod bearing wear is through regular oil analysis. Services like Blackstone Laboratories can analyze your used engine oil, identifying the presence of metals like copper, lead, and tin, all of which are indicative of bearing wear. Tracking these levels over time provides a much clearer picture than mileage alone.
- Baseline Samples: Take a sample of your oil immediately after an oil change to establish a baseline for comparison.
- Consistent Intervals: Submit samples at regular intervals, such as every oil change or every other oil change, depending on your driving habits.
- Trend Analysis: Pay close attention to trends rather than single data points. A sudden spike in wear metals warrants further investigation.
Listening for the Telltale Knock: Recognizing the Sound of Trouble
While oil analysis is proactive, a rod knock is a definitive sign of bearing failure. This is a distinct, rhythmic knocking sound, often most noticeable at idle or low RPMs.
- Cold Starts: The knock may be more pronounced when the engine is cold, as oil viscosity is higher and provides less cushioning.
- Load Sensitivity: The noise might increase under load, such as when accelerating or climbing a hill.
- Professional Diagnosis: If you suspect a rod knock, immediately consult with a qualified BMW mechanic for a proper diagnosis. Continuing to drive with a rod knock can lead to catastrophic engine damage.
Mileage Markers: Considering Time and Usage
While not a hard-and-fast rule, mileage can be a contributing factor.
- High Mileage Concerns: S85 engines with over 80,000 miles should be carefully monitored, as the risk of bearing failure increases with age and wear.
- Low Mileage Doesn’t Mean Safe: Even low-mileage examples can experience bearing failure, especially if they’ve been subjected to aggressive driving or infrequent oil changes.
- Preventative Maintenance Window: Many owners choose to replace the rod bearings between 60,000 and 80,000 miles as a preventative measure.
The rod bearing replacement on the S85 is a complex job that requires specialized tools, technical expertise, and meticulous attention to detail. It’s generally not recommended for DIYers without extensive experience working on BMW engines.
Dropping the Oil Pan: Accessing the Crankshaft
The first step involves removing the oil pan to gain access to the connecting rods and crankshaft. This requires removing underbody panels and potentially disconnecting other components depending on your vehicle.
- Thorough Cleaning: Clean the oil pan and surrounding areas thoroughly before removal to prevent contaminants from entering the engine.
- Inspect Oil Pump: While the oil pan is off, inspect the oil pump for any signs of wear or damage.
- Check for Debris: Carefully examine the oil pan for any metal shavings or debris, which can provide clues about the extent of bearing wear.
Removing Connecting Rod Caps: Exposing the Bearings
Once the oil pan is removed, you can access the connecting rod caps. These caps secure the connecting rods to the crankshaft.
- Proper Torque Specs: Use a torque wrench to loosen the connecting rod cap bolts to prevent damage. Follow BMW’s specified torque values during reassembly.
- Bearing Shell Inspection: Once the caps are removed, carefully inspect the bearing shells for wear patterns, scoring, or other damage.
- Organized Storage: Keep the connecting rod caps and bolts organized to ensure they are reinstalled in the correct location and orientation.
Replacing the Bearings: Installing the New Components
With the connecting rod caps removed, you can install the new rod bearings.
- Surface Preparation: Clean the connecting rod and crankshaft surfaces thoroughly before installing the new bearings.
- Proper Lubrication: Apply a generous amount of assembly lubricant to the new bearings to ensure proper lubrication during initial startup.
- Correct Orientation: Ensure the bearings are installed with the correct orientation. The tabs on the bearings must align with the notches in the connecting rod and cap.
Reassembly and Torqueing: Securing the Components
After installing the new bearings, you need to reassemble the connecting rod caps and torque the bolts to the manufacturer’s specifications.
- Torque Sequence: Follow BMW’s recommended torque sequence for the connecting rod cap bolts.
- Angle Torque: Many connecting rod bolts require a specific angle torque after the initial torque value is reached.
- Threadlocker (If Applicable): Some applications may require the use of threadlocker on the connecting rod bolts. Consult the BMW service manual for specific instructions.
Priming the Oil System: Ensuring Proper Lubrication
Before starting the engine, it’s crucial to prime the oil system to ensure the new bearings are properly lubricated.
- Disconnect Fuel Injectors: Disconnect the fuel injectors to prevent the engine from starting.
- Crank the Engine: Crank the engine for several seconds to allow the oil pump to circulate oil throughout the system.
- Monitor Oil Pressure: Observe the oil pressure gauge to ensure the system is properly primed.
Beyond the technical aspects, there are often overlooked factors that contribute to the long-term health of an S85 engine.
The Cold Start Dilemma: Minimizing Wear and Tear
Cold starts are particularly harsh on rod bearings. During a cold start, the oil is thicker, and it takes time for it to reach all parts of the engine. This temporary lack of lubrication can accelerate wear.
- Minimize Short Trips: Avoid frequent short trips, as the engine may not fully warm up, leading to increased wear.
- Warm-Up Procedure: Allow the engine to idle for a few minutes before driving, especially in cold weather.
- Gentle Driving Initially: Drive gently until the engine reaches operating temperature.
The Importance of Oil Choice: Selecting the Right Lubricant
The type of oil you use can significantly impact the longevity of your rod bearings.
- BMW LL-01 Specification: Use a high-quality synthetic oil that meets BMW’s LL-01 specification. This ensures the oil meets the engine’s specific requirements for lubrication and protection.
- Viscosity Grade: Consider the climate in which you drive. In colder climates, a lower viscosity oil may be preferable to ensure adequate flow during cold starts.
- Oil Additives: While some owners use aftermarket oil additives, it’s essential to research them thoroughly and ensure they are compatible with your engine. I have personally found that sticking with a high-quality, LL-01 approved oil is sufficient and avoids potential compatibility issues.
Beyond the Bearings: Addressing Related Components
While replacing the rod bearings is a crucial step, it’s also an opportunity to address other potential issues.
- Connecting Rod Bolts: Consider replacing the connecting rod bolts with new ones, as they are often stretch bolts that are designed for single use.
- Oil Pump Inspection: Inspect the oil pump for wear and replace it if necessary. A failing oil pump can lead to inadequate lubrication, even with new rod bearings.
- VANOS System: The VANOS (Variable Valve Timing) system is another potential source of problems on the S85 engine. Consider inspecting and servicing the VANOS system while the engine is partially disassembled.
The S85 community is a wealth of knowledge and experience. Here are some valuable insights shared by owners who have tackled the rod bearing replacement:
The Peace of Mind Factor: Preventative Replacement vs. Waiting
Many owners opt for preventative rod bearing replacement for the peace of mind it provides. Knowing that the bearings have been replaced eliminates a significant source of anxiety and allows them to enjoy their M5 or M6 without worrying about potential engine failure.
- Weigh the Costs: Preventative replacement involves a significant upfront cost, but it can potentially save you from more expensive repairs down the road.
- Consider Your Risk Tolerance: If you are comfortable with the risk of potential engine failure, you may choose to wait for signs of bearing wear before replacing them.
- Long-Term Ownership: If you plan to keep your S85 for the long term, preventative replacement is a wise investment.
Choosing the Right Shop: Finding a Qualified Technician
The S85 rod bearing replacement is not a job for just any mechanic. It requires specialized knowledge and experience.
- BMW Expertise: Choose a shop that specializes in BMW repair and has a proven track record of successfully performing rod bearing replacements on S85 engines.
- References and Reviews: Ask for references and read online reviews to gauge the shop’s reputation.
- Communication and Transparency: Choose a shop that communicates clearly and provides transparent pricing.
The Value of Thorough Inspection: Catching Other Potential Issues
During the rod bearing replacement, a thorough inspection can reveal other potential issues that might otherwise go unnoticed.
- Crankshaft Condition: Inspect the crankshaft for any signs of damage or wear. If necessary, the crankshaft can be machined or replaced.
- Cylinder Walls: Check the cylinder walls for scoring or other damage.
- Leakage: Address any oil leaks or other fluid leaks that are discovered during the inspection.
The s85 rod bearing replacement is a significant undertaking, but with careful planning, informed decision-making, and the right expertise, you can ensure the longevity and performance of your S85 engine. By understanding the warning signs, following proper procedures, and learning from the experiences of others, you can navigate this potential pitfall and continue to enjoy the thrill of driving one of BMW’s most iconic engines.
Table: Comparing Rod Bearing Replacement Options
| Option | Description | Pros | Cons | Suitable For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Preventative Replacement | Replacing bearings before any symptoms appear, typically around 60-80k miles. | Peace of mind, avoids potential engine damage, potentially extends engine life. | Higher upfront cost, requires engine disassembly, may not be necessary if bearings are still healthy. | Owners planning long-term ownership, those with low tolerance for risk, high-performance enthusiasts. |
| Reactive Replacement | Replacing bearings after detecting signs of wear (e.g., rod knock, high oil wear). | Lower upfront cost (if caught early), only replaces bearings when necessary. | Risk of engine damage if symptoms are ignored, potentially more expensive repairs if damage occurs. | Owners comfortable with higher risk, those closely monitoring their engine’s condition. |
Welcome to our hub for all things bearings! Whether you're an engineer, a student, or simply curious, we provide in-depth knowledge, the latest news, and insightful articles covering a wide range of bearing types, applications, and industry trends. Explore our resources to enhance your understanding and stay informed about the world of bearings.
